Home / Straight Answers / Refinancing
Straight Answers · Refinancing
Should I go fixed or variable?
Bayley Clarke · Mortgage broker on the road · Last checked 11 November 2026 · 7 min read
The short answer
There is no universally right answer, and anyone who tells you they know where rates are going is guessing. Including me, including your bank, including the economists on the news.
The real question isn't "which one will be cheaper", because nobody can know that in advance. It's "what do I need this loan to do for my life". Fixing buys certainty. Variable buys flexibility. A split buys some of each. Once you know which of those your next few years actually depend on, the decision mostly makes itself, and the rest of this page is the detail underneath it.
What fixing actually buys you
One thing: certainty. For the length of the fixed term, your repayment doesn't move. You know exactly what leaves your account every month, which makes budgeting simple and takes the nightly news out of your finances entirely.
What fixing does not buy you is a win on rates. Fixing is not a bet you're supposed to win. The banks price their fixed rates on where they expect variable rates to go, and they've got whole teams of analysts working out exactly where to set them so that, whatever rates do, the bank still makes money off you. If you fix and rates fall, you'll pay more than you had to. If you fix and rates rise, you'll pay less. You can't know which in advance, and neither can anyone selling you a prediction. Fix for the certainty, not for the punt.
Rather see both on your own loan?
Thirty minutes. Fixed, variable and a couple of splits side by side, with the repayment difference monthly and weekly, so you're choosing between real numbers instead of headlines.
Rates went up again. Is fixing now too late?
Late to the party, is what I say. By the time rates have gone up a few times, the banks have already lifted their fixed rates to match, because those rises were built into the price before they happened. So fixing after the headlines is generally not a way to save money on what's coming. It's a way to buy certainty at today's price, which can still be worth doing, as long as you go in knowing that's what you're paying for. The full version is on Rates went up again. Should I fix?
I think of it as a personality spectrum. If a few more rises would genuinely keep you up at night, fixing buys you that peace of mind for a set period. If your cash flow is alright, you've got a buffer and you'd rather keep the offset and the extra repayments, you can weather the storm on variable and cop the rate as it moves.
What fixing costs you in flexibility
This is the part that catches people, because none of it shows up until your plans change.
- Extra repayments get capped. Each bank sets its own limit on additional repayments on a fixed loan, some per year, some across the whole fixed period. It's usually enough for the odd bonus or tax refund, not enough to pay the loan off. Go over it and break costs can come into it. The detail is on Can I pay extra off my home loan? Is there a penalty?
- Offset and redraw are usually limited. Some lenders offer a partial offset on fixed loans, many offer none. If your savings sitting against the loan is a big part of how you manage money, fixing can switch that off.
- Break costs if you leave early. Sell, refinance or pay the loan out inside the fixed term and the lender works out what your exit cost them. You don't control the size of it.
So the honest test for fixing isn't "do I like certainty". It's "am I confident nothing about this loan needs to change during the fixed window".
Breaking a fixed rate early: maybe, not yes or no
When you fix, the bank locks in its own funding for that period so it can guarantee your rate. If you walk out early, the break cost is the bank recovering what it loses, and what it loses depends on where rates are now compared with when you fixed. If rates have gone up since, the bank is itching for you to break it, because it can lend that money out again for more, and more than likely there's no break cost (some lenders still charge a smaller admin fee, so ask for the full number). If rates have dropped since, there's going to be a cost, and the bigger the drop, the longer you've got left and the more you owe, the bigger it generally is.
It can be anything from nothing to a figure big enough to wipe out the savings of switching, and only your bank can quote it on the day. Get the number before you decide. More on Will I get hit with break fees if I break my fixed rate early?
What variable buys you, and what it costs
Variable is the flexible option. On a variable loan there's generally no penalty for paying as much as you like: smash the mortgage, pay it off in full tomorrow, put money in, pull money out. A full offset account, so your savings work against the interest every day they sit there. Redraw when you need it. And no break costs, so you can sell, refinance or restructure whenever it suits your life rather than the calendar.
The cost is the obvious one: your repayment moves. When rates go down you get the benefit straight away, and when they go up your repayment rises with them, whether or not that month was a good one for it. Variable suits people whose budget can absorb movement. If a rise in your repayment would genuinely break your month, that's not a character flaw, it's information, and it points you back towards fixing at least part of the loan.
Split loans: you don't have to pick one
A split loan is pretty much just your home loan in parts instead of one whole. Fix part of it, leave the rest variable, and if rates move, half the loan moves and the other half stays put. The fixed portion holds most of your repayment steady, and the variable portion keeps the offset, the unlimited extra repayments and a clean exit on that slice.
It doesn't have to be half and half. Someone with big savings and a tight budget might fix most of it and size the variable slice to their offset balance. Someone about to sell a car, get a bonus or move in a partner's savings wants a decent variable split to absorb it. Splits also get used to keep money borrowed for different purposes apart, which matters more than people think at tax time. Keep it simple, though: every extra split is another balance to track, and plenty of people are better off with one loan and an offset. The two ways people use them are on What is a split loan, and how do people use it?
Fixing on a new loan, or the one you've already got
On a new loan, watch the date your rate is set. The banks are a bit cheeky here. With some exceptions, the rule of thumb is that your fixed rate is only locked in on settlement day, so the rate you applied for isn't necessarily the one you get. On a refinance that's a few weeks of exposure, on a purchase with a long settlement it can be months. A rate lock is a fee that stops the bank changing the fixed rate between lodgement and settlement. Some banks honour the fixed rate from approval and don't need one at all, which can make them the better pick over a slightly sharper advertised rate with a fee on top. See What is a rate lock, and should I pay for one?
On the loan you already have, it's easier than people expect. Going from variable to fixed with your current bank is generally just a request. They've already approved you for the loan, so they don't need to reassess whether you can afford it, even if your income has dropped since. You ask, they put you on the new fixed rate, and you're on your merry way. It's only switching banks that brings back the full assessment. More on Can my bank refix my rate if my income has dropped, or do I need to reapply?
The questions I actually ask before recommending either
- Is there any chance you'll sell inside the fixed window? If yes, fixing that portion puts break costs between you and the sale.
- Do you have lump sums coming? Bonus, inheritance, sale proceeds, a business having a good year. Fixed caps will get in the way of them.
- Does your budget survive a repayment rise? Not "would you dislike it", would it actually break. If it would, certainty has real value for you.
- Do you need the offset? If your savings sitting against the loan is central to how you run your money, going fully fixed can cost you more than it protects.
Want to see what each structure looks like on your loan?
Half an hour and I'll run it in front of you. Fixed, variable, and a couple of split options, against your actual income, savings and plans. Then you pick, knowing what each one costs you in flexibility and what it buys you in certainty.
No application, no credit check, nothing on your file. Just the numbers. · How I get paid
Common questions about fixed and variable
Should I go fixed or variable?+
There is no universally right answer, and anyone who tells you they know where rates are going is guessing. Fixing buys you certainty of repayment for the fixed term, variable buys you flexibility: offset, unlimited extra repayments, and no break costs if your plans change. The right pick depends on what you need the loan to do for your life, not on predicting the market.
Is it too late to fix after rates have gone up?+
Generally, fixing after a run of rises won't save you money on what's coming, because the banks price their fixed rates on where they expect rates to go and have usually lifted them already. What fixing still buys is certainty at today's price. If a few more rises would genuinely break your budget, that certainty can be worth paying for.
Can I fix half my loan and keep the rest variable?+
Yes. That's a split loan. The fixed part holds most of your repayment steady and the variable part keeps the offset, unlimited extra repayments and a clean exit on that slice. It doesn't have to be half and half: size the variable part to the savings and lump sums you expect to put against it.
Will I pay a fee to get out of a fixed rate early?+
Maybe. If rates have gone up since you fixed, there's usually little or no break cost, though some lenders still charge a smaller admin fee. If rates have dropped since you fixed, expect a break cost, and it grows with the size of the drop, the time left on the fix and the loan balance. Only your bank can quote the number on the day.
Can I pay extra off a fixed rate loan?+
Usually a little. Each bank sets its own cap on extra repayments during a fixed term, per year or across the whole fixed period, and going over it can trigger break costs. If you expect lump sums, keep a variable split with an offset so that money has somewhere to go without a penalty.
Do I have to reapply to fix my rate if my income has dropped?+
Generally not, if you're staying with your current bank. Moving from variable to fixed on your existing loan is usually just a request, because the bank has already approved the loan. The full reassessment of your income and expenses only comes back if you switch to a different bank.
Next question
My fixed rate is ending in a few months. What should I do to get ready?Do nothing and on expiry day you roll onto your bank's revert variable rate, whatever they set it at, usually above what new customers get.
Related answers
The full guide: Your fixed rate is ending: the 90 day plan Rates went up again. Should I fix? What is a split loan, and how do people use it? What is a rate lock, and should I pay for one? Will I get hit with break fees if I break my fixed rate early? Can I pay extra off my home loan? Is there a penalty? Can my bank refix my rate if my income has dropped, or do I need to reapply? Repricing versus refinancing: which one should I do first?Not your question? Book a call and ask it, or call 0437 189 939.